Seagullslost's Doctor Who (and others) audio reviews

Posts

Recent posts

Adrift Star Cops: Conflict 5.4 Still reeling from the Death of Alice Okoro, The Star Cops have to carry on. A vessel finds its way back into the Moons orbit. Previously stolen, with three dead and one survivor, the ISPF investigate. Although Alice is gone she’s not entirely forgotten, the stolen craft was her investigation. Nathan and Paul board the ship. The survivor terrified of a creature, yet they cant find any evidence of any such monster. The fact that Nathan starts hearing Alices voice, makes you wonder if the strain is taking its toll on him. The drifting ship is a classic sci/fi trope, though that’s probably the height of the sci/fi elements. Also it's not heavily dependant on continuity, so you can enjoy it on its own. The new Moonbase commander does feature in this, though I was expecting more to be made of the relationship. Some conflict or something, but it all seems just fine and not really adding much to the proceedings. You do get the suspicion of what going ...

Timewyrm: Exodus Doctor and Ace arrived in the early 1950’s UK. It's not long since the war was won or was it? It maybe England but the Nazis are in control , so what happened and where is the Timewyrm? Its such a pity that this wasn’t the first book in the series, if it had been I probably would have continued with the series when they originally came out, instead of giving up a couple of chapters into Genesis. A nazi occupied Britain story is a bit been there done that, two a penny these days, maybe not so much in the nineties. The nice thing is that it doesn’t linger there, in fact there are 3 or 4 time periods they visit over the course of the novel. This reflects the more adult nature of the new adventures in a much better way than book. Rather than the nudity/sexual tones, it manages it by Ace getting beaten up in order to look more convincing as a Nazi prisoner. There are some great moments with the Doctor doing his ‘look like you own the place’, by assumi...

Blood Of The Time Lords The Fourth Doctor Adventures 11.1 : Solo Discovering a book on the TARDIS and realising its too powerful, the Doctor takes it to a library on a moon of Gallifrey. Its not long before the trouble starts. I bought this by accident, a sale, I meant to get volume 2 but got this, so ended up with both sets. I’m not really a fan of the Fourth Doctor audios, but it doesn’t stop me from trying. Its set just after the Deadly Assassin, hence the solo traveling. Though Elanora (Emma Noakes) does take the companion role. I did quite enjoy the first couple of episodes. Some nice world building life on the moon, old friends of the Doctors. There’s a fire for which the Doctor is held responsible - leading to a nice cliffhanger. The usual fourth Doctor tropes - eg. being on trail. The library itself with endless shelves. Its perhaps a bit of a spoiler but the Master is involved the shot lived James Dreyfus version. I do wish I paid more attention or did my research as I ma...

The Monsters Of Gokroth Doctor Who The Monthly Adventures 250 The Doctor is on the planet Gokroth and so is an old friend: Mags. There’s a small settlement, plagued by monsters and a mad scientist… I found it quite difficult to get int the first episode. The Doctor only appears briefly, a couple of time before coming back at the end and Mags - our other entry into the story, as with the Doctor, isn’t the main focus. Instead there’s a village with a curfew, something about a radio transmitter, some scientist woman and her helper in a castle, with none of it really coalescing. Episode two and three things do get going, but it does end up with various encounters with monsters - and on audio its not great storytelling, and it all become mediocre . Epsiode four taking a more interesting turn as we find out what the deal is, and the motorvations of Dr Maleeva, to this point theres a feel of the Island of DR Moreau/Frankenstien - which the Doctor mentions. The Doctor says he’s been there for ...

The Mindless Ones Purity Undreamed 2.1 Hebe visits an old friend, while the Doctor and Mel investigate some odd readings. I listened to Gallifrey War room 1, and wasn’t getting into it, so decide to go for something a bit more light hearted and less intense. Though the first set in this range, was average at best, its still entertaining. As you’d expect Hebe friend isn’t quite the one she used to know, once a goth girl; she’s now more traditional. The Doctor visits the Mindless facility and goes through an interesting procedure. There’s nothing here thats new or original, The Doctors been brainwashed to be happier and less curious - to betterise himself as he puts it. But, just as the story seem to get going its all ends, and is a bit of a none adventure. I did think that perhaps there was a bigger story to come and this was just the start but there’s no evidence to suggest that. Hebe as a character is less defined, not quite as terse as she was. The most out standing part of the ...

Hooklight Part 2 The Fifth Doctor Adventures The story continues.. The TARDIS team have discovered Hooklight. Something that can stop time, it shouldn’t exist, and as a Timelord, the Doctor has to destroy it. Scattered through space and time, our hero’s fight on. Nyssa almost possessed by Hooklight, Adric thrown back in time, Can the Doctor find Tegan and get the crew back together? When I saw the reviews for part 2 I noticed that it hadn’t been rated quite as highly as part 1 and I’d have to agree. Thats not to say it isn’t good, it just doesn’t quite have the same grand scale as the first half, just a bit more mundane and routine. During the first episode you do wonder whats happened to Tegan, but then episode two is almost entirely devoted to her. Though I found it enjoyable, listenable, and it has consequences on her future, it does detract from the main plot. As mentioned in Hooklight 1 each of the TARDIS crew had a purpose, the were driven, now its less so. I feel the need to pra...

The First Days Of Phaidon Gallifrey War Room 1.4 The planet Phaidon - an early casualty of the Time War has suddenly returned, both the Timelords and Daleks are eager to get there. I seem to be in the minority on this as it did little for me. Though this set in general hasn’t done much for me, part three being the exception. Maybe its me, maybe its Time War stuff, maybe I’m just tired. The return of Narvin is a plus point, and mentions of Romana and Ace. It does help to have a good memory Warpwrights and Phaidon go back to the first Gallifrey audio, which I’ve not listened to since its release in 2004! As with a lot of US TV series, coming back to continue a year later its a stuggle to remember what was happening last time. I’ll give it another go at some point and see if I enjoy it more, but for now, its average.

Collateral Victim Gallifrey War Room 1.3 The Norvis galaxy: whatever happens its gets destroyed. Either the Daleks take over and turn it into weapon manufacturings, or the Timelords wipe it from existence to stop them. Though the Timelord Bandar was sent enact its removal from time ,it seems the planet Mellacron has somehow evaded its deletion. Leela, Velkin and Rasmus are sent to to investigate. Its amazing how much is packed into this hour long episode. They find themselves on Mellacron, but also drift into different time zones. Bandar arrived much earlier and has been advancing technology, but even he doesn’t know the full story. It does illustrate how far the TImelords are willing to go, in winning the war, and, as with the War Doctor, some decisions are not easy. Though there is little evidence that any Gallifrayan is bothered by the actions the ‘have’ to take. Some of Veklins deeds are questionable and it does make for an interesting drama. There are a number of twists and turns,...

The Passenger Gallifrey: War Room 1.2 A Dalek ship is heading for Gallifrey, but there’s only one occupant - a Timelord. Its Leela’s job to make contact. A lot of this audio seems just about trying to verify that the Timelord is who he says he is: Kalgoth. He’s the only survivor of a battle with the Daleks and his memory has been affected. Leela herself is quite sedate, following orders quite obediently. I was expecting something to come of it but no, not here anyway. Also she’s not a major character in this episode either. With no Romana or Narvin, she’s the only constant of the Gallifrey series.The others are present, Veklin, Olistra - I’ve been trying to remember why I know the voice, its Carolyn Pickles I know her from the TV series Bluebells, but that was a long time ago. It has the usual twists and turns, but the fact is that every time I came back to continue listening I found I couldn’t remember what was happening and had to go back. For the last 15 minutes I did consider just ...