Seagullslost's Doctor Who (and others) audio reviews

The Ravencliff Witch                               The Fourth Doctor Adventures 11.2                                                                        Dull as dishwater. Its a classic, classic Doctor Who setup. Small English costal town, newly built power station, and an old story of witch sightings.  With people vanishing with only a dark shadow on the wall (which I’m sure been done elsewhere). The Doctor getting into trouble after seeing something in the sea. The fact that the witch has been spotted over the centuries, signalling a death. And something alien. Its all quite promising. The Doctor does his thing of pretending he’s someone important in order to view the power station. Though he gets caught out, I was silently sc...

Peepshow                                                   The Diary Of River Song 6.3                                                                                A power source from an old Miniscope, is what River is after,. However its one the Doctor once had an dalliance with… I’ll start by saying that I listened to the first series of the Diary of River Song and I wasn’t that impressed, so not bothered since. I think also its an excuse not to but more. This was a freebie though. This serves as a kind of sequel to Carnival Of Monsters, but as with the Classic Doctors, New Monsters sets, its largely rehashing the original story. River gains a companion Dibbsworth...

Vampire Weekend                                   The Thirteenth Doctor Audios 1.1                                                      Yaz is off on her own travels as she attends a hen party - a house in the middle of nowhere, not thats its going to plan, as the bride to be hasn’t been invited. If that wasn’t enough the Doctor shows up looking for a vampire. This is classic Doctor Who, well classic Big Finish Doctor Who anyway. A base under siege type. The Doctor creates a forcefield to stop the Vampire she’s been tracking from escaping, leaving the monster trapped in with them. It reminds me of the film clue, since the vampire is disguised as one of the guests. Its a standard story, nothing new or unique, but it is a chance to showcase the thirteenth Doctor on audio. ...

Tick Tock Star Cops: Conflict 5.5 A somewhat nervous worker on a moonwalk, and shooting down drones - fairly run of the mill stuff. Just a normal day on Moonbase, until a message comes though that Moonbase will be destroyed… The nervous worker Vanessa, seemed quite happy up to recently. Confident in her work, and outgoing, being so eager to leave raises suspicions. It also made me think when they put her into the cells. I remember the Tv series when Nathan first found the office for the ISPF - the rather cramped conditions. I’ve never really considered how things have moved on. Having cells, interview rooms etc. Tick Tock, it doesn’t take much to work out what it referring to. They ISPF get a message - a missile to heading to Moonbase. It brings some interesting events, whether the message is real or not. There’s nice discussions with the ISPF and the Coordinator about who has the say in evacuating Moonbase, It could cost billions if its a hoax, but many will die if its not. There are ...

False Friends The Ninth Doctor Adventures An SOS calling for the Doctor takes the Ninth and Rose to a solitary planet in a nebula, where everything is fake, a copy of Earth but not quite. Its a great start as the pre titles has the Ninth asking Rose (or Roses’) to prove she’s (or they’re) human. So mystery from the off. As the narrative shifts to the planet in question, we’re introduced to Minnie and Gary - quite possibly the only real people on the planet.  The thing about this world is that its an imitation of Earth, almost like a computer game, where its all there but made to look like it, rather than actually being it. So its intriguing, whats going on? Who built it and why? Whats adds to the suspense is waiting for the plot to get round to the opening sequence. Its hard to write without spoilers, but something returns. It its a nice moment when its revealed and one or two references that are great for long term fans. One scene reminded me of a Red Dwarf episode - Psirens, and ...

The Moons of Vulpana                            Doctor Who The Monthly Range 251                                                                     Having joined the Doctor on the TARDIS, The Doctor takes Mags back to her home world Vulpana. As there’s not much left of it now, they go back to a golden age. I quite enjoy stories that explore the backgrounds of characters or monsters. The Domain Of The Voord springs to mind. Mags - a Werewolf, transforms under the second Moon and so they meet more of her kind, being a pure blood she is highly sought after and has three brothers falling all over her, to win her heart. Ok so not exactly want I want form Who and the Doctor seems a secondary character but I didn’t mind, though I did wonder where it was hea...

The Rogue Planet                                                      Rose Tyler - The Dimension Cannon 2 Other Worlds 2.2                                                                         Both Rose and Jackie visit another Earth, where they meet themselves… I’ve not heard the first set so I can only go but these three stories in the ‘Other Worlds’ set. This is the most interesting of the three. Mostly because its not that unlike our own, and feels more plausible. The Jackie on this world is a Tv star, while Rosie is a single mother who runs a cafe. I do have to hand it to Camille Coduri, her other Jackie voice it great, and at first I thought maybe it was a different act...

Now Is The New Dark Rose Tyler - The Dimension Cannon 2 Other Worlds 2.2 Rose arrives on an Earth thats less developed than what she’s used to. Luckily Clive has come with her. It seems to still be in the Dark Ages and they find themselves out after curfew… Melancholics, of which Clive is designated as such are to be separated, there are murders and an alternative Jackie is also present. Its a pretty standard affair, coming over as a cross between the Happiness Patrol and the Witchfinders. There’s the idea that the Doctor is there, though as we know its not going to be him,  the tease doesn’t really work for the listener. Things are not quite as they would seem to be and is perhaps, for me, the redeeming feature of this run of the mill story. There’s nothing new here, nothing thats stands out as original. The fact that I have little to say about it, places mid range. No Bad, Not great, entertaining yes, but thats about it.

Saltwater Rose Tyler - The Dimension Cannon 2 Other Worlds Rose visits a world where both Pete and Jackie Tyler are dead. Someone is taking the salt out of the sea causing accidents, those involving military vessels, and governments are blaming each other. I’ve not hard the first series, but this was on sale. Its not hard to get the gist, Rose traveling to alternative universes, trying to find the Doctor. Also to help is Clive best remember for being in the first new series episode Rose. Billie Piper is great as aways, though making the Doctor out to be almost divine is a little much for me. Though Rose did tend to put him on a pedestal. There is interest in that Pete and Jackie may have been killed due to them being activists, exposing the truth, coverups etc. The fact that this word may have technology that Rose could use to contact the Doctor seemed to be the only reason Rose was hanging about. She was confined to a polic box at one point, only in that dimension its red. This series...